I spent last weekend in Saskatoon at the
Saskatchewan Writers' Guild's
annual fall conference. Among the events was a joint reading by two
renowned Canadian writers, science fiction author
Robert J. Sawyer and poet George
Elliot Clarke.
It should surprise no reader of my column that I
generally prefer readings by SF writers to readings by poets. I have even
been known to repeat the comment of Robert Heinlein's famed
science-fictional character Lazarus Long that "A poet who reads his verse
in public may have other nasty habits."
But I'm not really against poetry readings--just bad
poetry readings. George Elliot Clarke's reading was a good poetry reading,
and thus both interesting and entertaining. And, it turns out, it may even
have been good for his health.
German physiologists reported this summer on an
experiment that found that reciting lines from Homer's Odyssey
results in a greater synchronization of cardiovascular and respiratory
responses. Normally they're only rarely synchronized: rhythmic
fluctuations in blood pressure take place naturally in 10-second-long
cycles (called Mayer waves), whereas spontaneous breathing usually takes
place at a rate of 15 breaths per minute. Getting those two cycles in sync
may lower blood pressure and boost lung function--healthy for everyone,
and especially helpful for heart patients.
The physiologists, led by Dirk Cysarz of the
Herdecke Community Hospital and Institute of Mathematics at the University
of Witten/Herdecke, chose Homer's Odyssey for a very poetic reason:
its meter.
The Odyssey, in common with many other
ancient epic poems, is written in hexameter--six "metrons" or "feet"
(rhythmic units) per line. More specifically, much of the Odyssey
(and its companion, the Iliad) is written in dactylic hexameter. A
dactyl is a collection of three syllables, the first long, the other two
short. An ideal line of dactylic hexameter, then, consists of six feet,
each of which has three syllables. In practice, it's hard to keep this up,
so it's considered acceptable to replace some dactyls with spondees, which
are feet with two long syllables.
I can sense your eyes glazing over. Perhaps an
example is in order. This is the one all my references seem to use:
Down in a | deep dark | hole sat an | old pig |
munching a | bean stalk.
This works out to
dactyl | spondee | dactyl | spondee | dactyl |
spondee
but is still considered dactylic hexameter.
The researchers chose this form of poetry, seldom
used by English-speaking writers, because one of the collaborators on the
project, speech therapist Petric Von Bonin, had extensive experience with
it and thought they might get good results from it. As well, there are
historical accounts of Greek choruses and audiences reciting more than
10,000 lines of hexametric poetry without pausing. If it hadn't been
somehow enjoyable to do so, no one would have stuck it out. Finally, the
researchers had a German translation of the Odyssey that maintained
the poem's hexameter.
They team had 17 healthy subjects, average age 43,
take part in three different sessions, always at the same time of day. In
each session, the subject performed a different exercise: reciting
hexameter (repeating back phrases read to them by a researcher),
controlled breathing at six breaths per minute (one breath per Mayer wave,
in other words), or spontaneous breathing. All three exercises were done
both while at rest and while exercising. The subject's heart rate and
airflow were recorded simultaneously.
The results were unambiguous. As the subjects
recited Homer's poem, their breathing rates slowed and became more
synchronized with their heart rates. Controlled breathing had the same
effect (though not quite as pronounced)--but the subjects found the poetry
recitation enjoyable, whereas they found controlled breathing exercises
boring. During spontaneous breathing, there was little synchronization at
all.
This isn't the first study to find that recitation
can affect physiology. Previous research has examined the effects of
reciting the Rosary devotion--"Hail Mary"--and the "OM" yoga mantra. Both
also reduced respiration levels to six breaths a minute, and their ability
to achieve that result may explain their popularity, just as hexameter's
ability to do so may explain why ancient Greeks were willing to recite
10,000 lines of it at a sitting.
The effect was only found if the poetry was read
carefully, with every line syllable carefully pronounced and a quiet
breath taken after every half line.
In other words, good poetry reading is beneficial,
bad poetry reading is not.
That's good news for George Eliot Clarke...at least,
if he ever takes up writing dactylic hexameter.
These weekly columns on science appear
in the Regina
(Saskatchewan) Leader Post and Red Deer (Alberta) Advocate. They are
available for one-time publication or regular syndication to any
interested newspapers, magazines or on-line publications.
E-mail me for details.
If this column is valuable to you,
please consider making a donation.
Just click the button below. Thanks!